Candidate set
The metric requires a history of comparable variants rather than one published winner.
PBO studies candidate behaviour across partitions and estimates whether the selection procedure rewards a random peak.
Challenge the candidate before risk
The metric requires a history of comparable variants rather than one published winner.
In-sample ranks are compared with out-of-sample behaviour for the same variants.
High PBO signals that the space or economic mechanism needs revision.
PBO estimates procedure overfitting, not the probability of a future losing trade.
Treat holdout, time stability, multiple-testing correction and stress paths as separate evidence. Agreement matters more than one green metric.
Protect unseen data
Record every trial
Accept FAIL and insufficient data
Validation verdict
Historical, statistical and model results do not promise future returns. kquant provides computational tools and technical execution, but does not assess whether a specific trade is suitable for a user.